Are US threats making Iran rethink retaliation against Israel?

Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei meets with Palestinian group Hamas' top leader Ismail Haniyeh in Tehran, Iran July 30, 2024.
Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei meets with Palestinian group Hamas' top leader Ismail Haniyeh in Tehran, Iran July 30, 2024.
Reuters

The US has been scrambling to de-escalate tensions in the Middle East in the wake of attacks that killed top figures in Hamas and Hezbollah. Iran and Hezbollah have both vowed to retaliate against Israel over the assassinations, though it remains unclear when or how they’ll strike back.

New reporting suggests Tehran, which wants to avoid a wider war, may not pursue a large-scale response and could take a more limited approach — such as targeting Mossad. And the US has reportedly warned Iran that its new government and economy would be at “serious risk” if it moves forward with a significant attack against the Jewish state.

But Gregory Brew, an Iran expert at Eurasia Group, says he hasn’t seen anything from the Iranian side to back up the notion Tehran is planning to “scale back its response.”

“It’s not at all unusual that Iran is taking its time before responding, as it did in April when it waited two full weeks,” says Brew, referencing the massive barrage of missiles and drones Iran fired at Israel in retaliation for a deadly strike on its Damascus consulate.

The April attack was overwhelmingly intercepted by Israel and its allies. Had there been heavy civilian casualties, it’s possible an all-out war could’ve broken out in the region.

However they move forward in the days ahead, both Iran and Hezbollah are “likely to avoid causing significant civilian casualties, which Israel has indicated as a red line,” says Brew, because neither wants to end up in a wider war. But it’s a “tough line for Iran and Hezbollah to walk, and if the attacks do cause more damage than anticipated, there will be pressure within Israel to respond in kind, raising the risks of a broader regional escalation that could potentially pull in the US,” adds Brew.

Hezbollah has pledged to retaliate with or without allies. But the response is still likely to be “unmistakably launched in a coordinated fashion,” says Brew, even if Hezbollah and Iran attack different targets at separate times.

More from GZERO Media

Listen: What does global energy transition look like in a time of major geopolitical change, including rebalancing of trade? In this special episode of "Energized: The Future of Energy,” host JJ Ramberg and Enbridge CEO Greg Ebel talk to Arjun Murti, partner at Veriten and founder of the energy transition newsletter Super-Spiked. They discuss the impact of President Trump’s new energy policies, the role of North America in the global energy transition, and the possible impact of tariffs and trade tension on the energy sector.

President Donald Trump speaks as he signs executive orders and proclamations in the Oval Office at the White House on April 9, 2025.

REUTERS/Nathan Howard

With stock markets plunging and US Treasury yields reaching new heights, Donald Trump finally reneged on parts of his widescale tariff plan on Wednesday, declaring a 90-day pause to the far-reaching “reciprocal” levies that he introduced just one week ago while leaving a 10% across-the-board duty in place. He also escalated the already-burgeoning trade war with China by increasing the tariff on their imports to 125%.

EU and Chinese flags in an illustration.

REUTERS/Dado Ruvic/Illustration

European leaders have much to worry about concerning trade and economic growth, and they’re exploring their options with China at a time when Beijing has a strategic interest in helping to divide the US from Europe. Demonstrating to EU leaders that China can become a force for stability in global trade at a time when Donald Trumpis waging a trade war on allies and rivals alike would further that goal.

Democratic Republic of Congo's former President Joseph Kabila, attends a memorial service of Sam Nujoma, who became Namibia's first democratically elected president., February 28, 2025.
REUTERS/Siphiwe Sibeko

Former Democratic Republic of Congo President Joseph Kabila has announced his return to the country, vowing to halt the rapid advance of the Rwanda-backed M23 rebels who have seized significant territory in the country’s conflict-ridden east.

From left to right, Prime Minister of Bavaria Markus Soeder, Chairman of the CDU Friedrich Merz, Heads of the SPD Lars Klingbeil, and Saskia Esken arrive at a press conference after successful coalition negotiations in Berlin, Germany, on April 9, 2025.
Emmanuele Contini/NurPhoto via Reuters

Germany’s leading establishment parties reached a grand coalition deal on Wednesday, bringing Europe’s largest economy a step closer to having a formal government amid severe domestic and global challenges.

Jess Frampton

Globalization helped make the United States the most prosperous nation in history. But many Americans feel they haven’t benefited from free trade and voted for Donald Trump to “liberate” them from the system the United States built over the past 80 years. He is delivering.