Why regulating cross-border digital trade is tricky

Cross border trade inspections.
Cross border trade inspections.
GZERO Media

During the pandemic, many more people around the world ditched brick-and-mortar stores to order stuff online and have it delivered to their doorstep. And the trend isn’t going away.

But the convenience of getting almost anything you want with a few taps of your phone doesn't mean it's easy for the companies selling you the goods or services — or for the governments weighing the need for new rules to regulate cross-border e-commerce.

What is cross-border digital trade? While there's no commonly accepted definition, the OECD says it's "digitally enabled trade in goods or services, whether digitally or physically delivered."

It covers e-commerce transactions between buyers and sellers located in different countries, where (normally) different digital trade rules apply. The lack of universal legislation can make it harder than you'd think to buy and sell digitally when the product — even data flows — is of foreign origin.

Most experts agree there should be rules to govern cross-border digital trade, but the devil is in the details. Free marketers believe red tape should be kept at a minimum for e-commerce to flow seamlessly from, let's say, a small carpet maker in the Middle East to customers in Europe.

But what if that small business uses an online selling platform that collects data in a way that conflicts with a country’s privacy laws? Or if the manufacturer uses chemicals banned by the destination country? What if the online transaction is powered by a server located in China that won’t allow an audit for local tax collection?

One of the thorniest debates is over data protection, where Europe is leading the way. Ever wonder why so many websites ask if you want to accept their cookies? Cookies help companies learn more about you – and especially how to appeal to you. But in Europe, they are considered personal data. So if companies do business in the EU, which (arguably) has the world's most advanced online data protection law, cookie consents are a must.

The bloc’s General Data Protection Regulation gives EU residents the right to demand all the data any firm has collected on them. Failure to consent can mean big trouble.

The flip side is that while this is a great way to keep Big Tech from stealing your data, non-EU small businesses that sell to the EU can find the GDPR too onerous because they rely on third-party data to find customers. Some are even opting out of the EU market altogether to avoid the requirement.

So, what's the best way forward? Ideally, a global system would create a level playing field for small businesses to get a fair shot at expanding their overseas customer base but stop them from collecting buyers' data and selling it to third parties. To be effective, though, it would need to have a broad consensus, be easy to implement, and have teeth so bad actors could be held accountable.

But if we've learned anything from the experience of the World Trade Organization in trying to settle disputes between the US and China, it’s that enforcing trade rules will be anything but easy.

More from GZERO Media

- YouTube

As the Trump administration continues to reshape US foreign policy and retreat from global commitments, does that create an opportunity for China to step in? On GZERO World, Ian Bremmer is joined by Bill Bishop, writer of the Sinocism newsletter, for a wide-ranging conversation on China's political and economic landscape under President Xi Jinping and global ambitions in the wake of Trump 2.0.

Russian President Vladimir Putin could talks with President Donald Trump as early as this week. Artem Priakhin/SOPA Images via Reuters Connect
Artem Priakhin/SOPA Images via Reuters Connect

US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin will discuss America’s 30-day ceasefire proposal this week after Ukraine endorsed the plan last Tuesday but Putin torpedoed it with a list of conditions.

President Donald Trump looks on as military strikes are launched against Yemen's Iran-aligned Houthis over the group's attacks against Red Sea shipping, at an unspecified location in this handout image released March 15, 2025.

White House/Handout via REUTERS

The United States launched widespread strikes on the Iran-backed Houthis in Yemen on Saturday, killing 53 people and injuring 98 — mostly women and children — as it targeted military sites and a power station in the rebel group’s southwest stronghold.

President Donald Trump speaks to reporters before boarding Air Force One as he departs from Joint Base Andrews in Maryland, on March 14, 2025.

REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque

On Saturday, a judge pulled the plug on President Trump's plans to expel Venezuelans supposedly linked to gangs, temporarily blocking the White House from using a law from 1798 to do so. The judge ordered the administration to turn around any planes that were already en route, but more than 200 Venezuelans reportedly landed in El Salvador after the ruling.

Listen: In seven short weeks, the Trump administration has completely reshaped US foreign policy and upended trade alliances. Will China benefit from US retrenchment and increasing global uncertainty, or will its struggling economy hold it back? On the GZERO World Podcast, Bill Bishop, a China analyst and author of the Sinocism newsletter, joins Ian Bremmer for a wide-ranging conversation about China—its domestic priorities, global administration, and whether America’s retreat from global commitments is opening new doors for Beijing.

German Chancellor-in-waiting Friedrich Merz speaks to the media after he reached an agreement with the Greens on a massive increase in state borrowing just days ahead of a parliamentary vote next week, in Berlin, Germany, on March 14, 2025.
REUTERS/Axel Schmidt

Germany’s election-winning center-right Christian Democratic Union/Christian Social Union, led by Friedrich Merz, and the Social Democrats have reached a preliminary agreement with the Green Party on a deal to exclude defense spending from the country’s constitutional debt break and establish a dedicated $545 billion fund for infrastructure investments.

A Russian army soldier walks along a ruined street of Malaya Loknya settlement, which was recently retaken by Russia's armed forces in the course of Russia-Ukraine conflict in the Kursk region, on March 13, 2025.

Russian Defence Ministry/Handout via REUTERS

The Russian leader has conditions of his own for any ceasefire with Ukraine, and he also wants a meeting with Donald Trump.